Sunday, June 18, 2017

Melito of Sardis: Modalism and the Passover Homily

It has been a few years since I perused the writings
of Melito in any detail. However, it appears safe to assert
that he was a modalist, who thought Jesus possibly
exhausted the reality of God the Father, Son and
the holy spirit.

Jaroslav Pelikan (The Christian Tradition, volume I)
alludes to the words of Tertullian, who argued that
certain believers in or around his time "protect[ed]
the 'monarchy' of the Godhead by stressing the
identity of the Son with the Father without specifying
the distinction between them with equal precision"

Melito of Sardis was one such Monarchian, according to
Pelikan. He applied Psalm 96:10 to Jesus through
a so-called "christian midrash," whereby one
interprets the words "The Lord reigns from the tree"
as a polemic against Jews who opposed the glorious
Lord, Jesus Christ.

I notice that the Ecole Initiative states:

"The Peri Pascha addressed Marcionite teaching, even
if by extreme rhetoric. Jesus was not just prefigured
in the Hebrew scriptures, he was in the Hebrew
scriptures, suffering with the prophets, David, Moses,
Joseph, et al (415-504). Melito's graphic descriptions
of Jesus's death would be in direct opposition to the
docetic denial of Jesus' material body. Moreover,
Melito's modalism allowed him to affirm that God was
in all of these events and that he even suffered as
the person of Jesus. Marcionites must have found this
link to the Hebrew scriptures coarse and distasteful."


David Waltz said...

Hi Edgar,

I agree with you and Pelikan—i.e. Melito of Sardis was a modalist.

I posted a thread on this issue back on 12-05-11 that you might find of some interest [LINK].

Grace and peace,


Matt13weedhacker said...

Hi Edgar.

Here's a link to the "Peri Pascha" (Chester Beatty XII) manuscript at CSNTM

It begins on the third line from the top, first image.

CSNTM Image Id: 137221
CSNTM Image Name: BP_XII_013b_k.jpg

Contents of the MS:

f. 13v = Enoch 106.8–18;
f. 13r = Enoch 106.19–107.3
f. 13r = Melito 1–4
f. 14v7 = Melito 5–14;
f. 14r = Melito 14–20
f. 15r = Melito 21–26;
f. 15v = Melito 27–35
f. 16r8= Melito 35–42;
f. 16v = Melito 42–47

Edgar Foster said...

Thanks for the additional information. Weedhacker, very interesting material to me.